I m here to do business, not politics…and business is about bottomlines,"
Suzuki Motor chief Osamu Suzuki said on his first visit to India years ago. He
was talking cars and his joint venture with the Indian government–which gave
birth to Maruti Udyog, and to the redefinition of the automobile business in
India. Years later, as IT tries to emulate the feat and put India on an even
higher global pedestal, both segments face a common problem, in varying degrees.
While the auto sector has been through a churn of plenty, with big names
dropping out, the IT industry remains in the grips of a squeeze that refuses to
go away. While auto struggles back to its feet, IT stutters…the result–the
globe sits and watches, for in these two segments rest the fortunes of global
And the stuttering of the IT sector has had a fallout on its sub-segments.
Software and services have been a casualty, with growth rates down to single
digits. Hardware has taken a fall, with signs of revival only becoming visible
of late. By far the worst hit have been beleaguered dot-coms and advertising,
the last being the mirror of the health of any industry segment.
Hit where it hurts most
The Internet was intended to bring advertisers and marketers face-to-face
using cutting-edge innovation, preventing wastage of advertisements and
maximizing budget controls. Media support services were designed to help
optimize the advertising process. For, by utilizing the highly-efficient
targeting technology (like DoubleClick and RightServe), the advertiser could
focus on the audience he wanted, at the right time and place.
The US-based e-Marketer’s reports on e-advertising predict that by 2003,
sales of traditional banners on websites would drop to 41 per cent of total
online ad spend, with strategic sponsorships growing to 31 per cent. Sponsorship
on the Web is more than merely evaluating the URL and backing it with money. It
depends on whether a site has content and marketing plans to make it memorable.
Intel, for example, had sponsored a festival section on Satyam Online, which
gave information on Indian festivals, with games and promos thrown in for good
measure. The aim was to drive registration to Intel’s personal technology
section. Tracking and accountability, facilitated through targeting technology,
helped advertisers on the Net assess returns on investment. These monitored
advertisements and allowed the advertiser to make necessary changes. Most
importantly, they could actually quantify returns on investment.
Two years back, the strategy worked. Today, there are no such success
stories. The same Intel is finding it tough to spread its education program in
India using the Web–content is simply not available. In China, Korea and
Japan, Intel has no such problem with local content. Bottomline–we may have
the numbers, we don’t have quality.
Quite clearly, mediocrity has become the order of the day. Imagine the plight
of a media planner at an advertising agency; with around 25 publications
nationwide to choose from… where would he turn when he has thousands upon
thousands of websites, each claiming to be comprehensive and the best? So where’s
the future? With the Net coming in over cables, instead of scarce phone lines,
and the PC being replaced by cheaper gadgets, portals will be the gateways of
eCommerce. With 42 million homes connected to cable television, the Internet
could, with new cables and equipment, be accessed at a speed 600 times faster
through cable modems. The effects will be palpable.
To sum up, a quote from a story by Mindtree’s Ashok Soota on the Internet
revolution–"eBusiness is not about selling on the Net, but building
eBrands. It is not just an infotech issue, but a strategic one that should
establish deep relationships with customers. It has to be business-led, not
Somewhere, in the mad scramble to clamber on to the bandwagon, we have
forgotten all the wise words.
Rajeev Narayan,in New Delhi