Notebooks

author-image
DQI Bureau
New Update

Like
Desktops, product is the most important parameter of CIO satisfaction in this
category. And vendors seem to have understood this very well as the level of CIO
satisfaction in this category is also the highest.

Advertisment

However, unlike the previous
year where pre sales and marketing was an important determinant, post sales
service has become a key buying parameter. It is not too difficult to reason
this out.

Given that notebooks are going the desktop way on the pricing front,
CIOs are now worried about vendors' service networks rather than issues like
domain knowledge of vendors or quality of pre sales and marketing interaction.


Again it is interesting to note that the average satisfaction scores have moved
up indicating that vendors have worked hard to raise the satisfaction bar.

Advertisment

Dell, which occupies the number one slot in the Desktop category, has jumped
two places to move to number two slot in the notebooks category. IBM seems to
have taken a beating on both the desktop and notebooks segment.

While IBM seems
to have done a good job in keeping CIOs happy-its satisfaction score has moved
up from to 78 to 83, other players have done a better job.

The new IBM-Levano
combine has a task cut out for itself to take the 'ThinkPad' to the top slot
in face of the ever-increasing competition. Acer continues to be at the bottom
of the satisfaction chart and is the only company that has not seen a good jump
in its satisfaction score compared to last year and is way below the industry
average.

Advertisment

What is surprising is that Acer has not moved up significantly on the
'Price' parameter despite introducing many products at the most competitive
rates. We think that Acer needs to convey the price-advantage to CIOs more
aggressively. Dell has pipped Acer on price to take the top slot.

Notebooks
Scorecard
Rank-05Rank-04
HP12
Dell24
IBM31
Toshiba43
Acer55
How
the Brands Fared

Parameters

IndustryHPIBMAcerToshibaDellOthers
Product
(100)
84.986.385.77684.387.181.5
Pre
sales & marketing (74)
83.68684.97884.984.183.2
Price
& commercial (70)
80.581.280.276.581.481.880
Delivery
& installation (70)
83.485.483.175.483.183.582.4
Post
sales service (83)
80.98481.275.180.980.974.7
Note:
The table indicates the overall satisfaction scores of the
notebook vendors on the listed parameters. The parameters have
been ranked according to the order of importance and the red
numbers in the brackets indicate relative importance. The
figures in blue are for the vendors with the highest
satisfaction scores for that particular parameter.
Base:
526
Dataquest-IDC
India: Customer Satisfaction Audit 2005

Notebooks:
How CIOs Rate the Vendors

IndustryHPIBMAcerToshibaDell
Product
Product
reliability
868886768488
Warranty/replacement
scheme
848684768486
Maintenance
need
848684748486
Ease
of integration with existing setup
848486768688
Post
Sales Service
Responsiveness828482768082
Proactiveness808480768082
Expertise
to resolve problem
808482748080
Dataquest-IDC
India: Customer Satisfaction Audit 2005
The
satisfaction scores are on a 100-point scale with 100 being
the highest-very satisfied

Base: 526

HP
consistent performance on the both top parameters and their
sub parameters either meet or exceed the average industry
expectation. So it comes across as no surprise that HP tops
the CSA Index 2005 for the notebook category