Indian IT professionals have recently been at the receiving end, accused of
receiving preferential treatment over the US workforce and encroaching on jobs.
The negative sentiment created in places such as US, Singapore, Malaysia etc has
led to a political backlash and lobbying for stringent laws in the respective
countries to curb offshore outsourcing in the interest of job security.
|
Offshore outsourcing is real
But it is time for everyone to get wise and realize that offshore
outsourcing, even if considered only for its economic advantages, is here to
stay. The reality is that the Indian IT industry, especially the BPO space, is
very strong in terms of value creation and value enhancements. This is apart
from the traditional labor cost advantages, high level of functional skills,
English-speaking skills and other drivers that shift global focus towards India.
This is the sentiment that Nasscom also conveyed to the American government
recently. There is no panic, but certain policy issues like changing visa
regulations and other bottlenecks are a cause for concern.
One can say that the BPO backlash has triggered hindrances in quite
unexpected areas. The issue of visa restrictions is quite irritating. The US
government is arbitrarily rejecting L1 visa, which is considered to be an easier
route over the H1. This is causing hardship to companies registered across
multiple locations, increasing costs and unplanned expenditure. The US
government is demanding that companies show unique skills of the personnel to
necessitate the relocation, which is very arbitrary. Most companies have
multiple locations and this procedure is slowing down business processes.
Reasons for such a backlash have been:
n Possible job
losses in the US due to outsourcing
n Increasing
pink slips being issued to cut costs
Germany, US, Singapore, Malaysia are some countries where this ‘trigger’
effect is increasingly being seen. Industry associations and the Indian
government have lodged their protests and are trying to make appropriate
countries realize the futility of it such acts.
Government contracts form a very small percentage...
No doubt the $10-billion software and services industry is important to
Indian companies. However, the legislative Bills proposed in several US states
would cover only a minor percentage of government contracts that make up a minor
chunk of the BPO deals that originate out of the US. In fact, more than half of
the world’s top 500 companies including GE, Amex, etc. outsource work to India
and will continue to do so.
Such acts will not sustain in the long run, as offshore outsourcing work is
nowadays driven more by economic considerations. Labor unions, trade groups and
industry associations will definitely drum up support against such contracts
being signed and depriving employment to local personnel, but in any case, these
will be restricted to the government sector and in the global offshoring
scenario, this forms a minor chunk of business.
Frequency of deals being signed by Indian BPO players for clients in the
United States is going up rapidly and hence India is increasingly being seen as
a threat. Coupled with these are the layoffs in big companies which are
occurring at regular intervals, prompting apprehensions about job losses.
Nasscom ’s moves laudable
The Nasscom initiative is helpful in countering such developments. Nasscom
has presented information to members of the Assembly State Government Committee
of New Jersey discussing the benefits of outsourcing to other countries as a
matter of cost cutting. Other Indian industry associations, suppliers and
influencers should take Nasscom’s cue.
The Indo-American Chamber of Commerce has suggested that India and US
administration should devise a mutually beneficial formula for the restoration
of outsourcing of any work from India, which has been obstructed by the New
Jersey Bill.
Industry associations should start lobbying with the Indian government, as
also with the American chambers to portray the advantages of sourcing business
processes to countries like India. More such efforts are necessary.
Avinash Vashitha
The author is managing director of NeoIT.