Advertisment

Everybody Wants to Eat EMC’s Lunch

author-image
DQI Bureau
New Update

It’s a humdrum office park 27 miles west of Boston. But through the ’90s,

the Hopkinton (Mass.) home of EMC Corp. (EMC ) was the global capital of the

soaring data-storage market. EMC’s stock rose from a split-adjusted 7 cents to

$101, making it the top performer in the Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index

during the ’90s.

Advertisment

The world was bursting with digital information, and EMC’s massive

disk-drive machines, regarded as the best of breed, gave companies around the

world a secure place to store every last bit. Naturally, it came at a premium

price. One competitor joked that "EMC" stood for Excessive Margin Co.

Those

margins are shriveling fast, as legions of competitors, including IBM,

Hewlett-Packard, Dell Computer, and dozens of upstarts, rush into the market.

They’re not all building the refrigerator-size machines that EMC made famous.

These days, even startups and midsize companies want storage, and they’re

demanding cheaper machines–all of them linked to networks. The key is no

longer simply to save the information but to manage and retrieve it faster.

That’s why on Aug. 20, Cisco Systems Inc. made a play to grab a bigger

chunk of network storage. It announced an agreement to purchase Andiamo Systems

Inc., a maker of storage switches. For now, Cisco is angling for leadership in

the $1 billion switch market, which is off EMC’s turf. "But Cisco may

have grander ambitions," says Steve Duplessie, founder of The Enterprise

Storage Group Inc. "Then it could get ugly for EMC."

Advertisment

EMC already has all the competition it needs. Its stock price has withered to

a mere 7% of its 2000 high, and HP, strengthened by its Compaq Computer Corp.

acquisition, has raced ahead in market share, with 25.6% to EMC’s 17.3%. The

question now is whether EMC CEO Joseph M. Tucci can lead the $7 billion company

through a wrenching transformation to software and services–without succumbing

to a takeover. To do so, he must match former IBM Chairman Louis V. Gerstner

Jr., who pulled off a similar makeover in the ’90s. That was a Herculean task.

What’s more, analysts say, EMC, a far smaller company than IBM, with a market

capitalization of $16.8 billion, could get even cheaper, becoming irresistibly

bite-sized as it struggles to remake itself in a merciless market. "Their

window is closing," says Ashok Kumar, senior research analyst

at U.S. Bancorp Piper Jaffray.

Who would buy EMC? Now that storage is growing in corporate networks,

practically every big tech company is pushing into the business. They all want

to sell a complete suite of digital offerings to their customers, and EMC,

despite its bumps and bruises, is still at the front of the class in storage

hardware and software. This would make the former highflier a juicy target not

only for IBM and HP but also for newcomers to storage such as Cisco and Dell.

Bear, Stearns & Co. analyst Andrew Neff predicts a possible HP-EMC merger.

Of course, HP, fresh from its Compaq purchase, won’t likely be in a courting

mood for a year. Still, the deal has a certain logic: EMC would provide HP with

its own top-of-the-line offering, Neff says–while breaking up EMC’s

increasingly chummy relations with Dell.

EMC’s ability to remain independent hinges on software. The big challenge

is to come up with a program that stitches together today’s crazy quilt of

storage systems. The typical data center has several types of storage boxes on

its floor that can’t talk to one another or share storage space if one gets

overloaded. The magic bullet for them would be software that connects them all

and automates management, taking much of the manual labor–and cost–out of

the process.

Advertisment
A

Powerful Packof Competitors
Its share rose from 12.7% in 2000 to 15.6% in ’01, while EMC’s fell from 20% to 17.3%. It hopes to up the ante with software linking storage and networks.
The acquisition of Compaq made HP No 1 in storage. It now rules the fast-growing midsize market with a 41% share, vs. EMC’s 6%. On Aug. 20, it said it would share key technical specs with IBM.
A punishing hardware market has pushed longtime storage leader EMC into the red and battered its stock. EMC’s goal now is to move into more profitable storage software and services. The risk: head-on collisions with burly rivals.
As storage moves onto networks, it enters Cisco’s realm. On Aug. 20, the company took a big step into storage networking by agreeing to buy switchmaker

Andiamo.
Last year, it partnered with EMC to sell midrange storage boxes. Now Dell plans to make and sell a low-end unit, using EMC technology. The risk: Dell’s knowhow will grow until it no longer needs EMC.

EMC engineers are racing to come up with just such magic. A program called

AutoIS promises to let corporate managers store and retrieve data no matter what

machine it resides on. Trouble is, rivals are following suit–and AutoIS isn’t

complete, though a big piece is due in October.

Tucci doesn’t downplay the immense job ahead. He’s too busy mapping out a

plan for his specialty business to survive in a world of giants. The strategy:

EMC, in the fashion of Japan’s keiretsu, teams up with a group of service

partners, including Accenture and Electronic Data Systems, to sell and install

the systems. And an eventual merger? "I don’t spend a second worrying

about it," he says. He has more immediate concerns. Hardware makes up 56%

of his business, and prices are plunging at least 30% a year. This is likely to

help drive down revenue from $7 billion last year to $5.7 billion in 2002, while

earnings tumble from last year’s $168 million, excluding restructuring charges

of $825 million, to a net loss of $84 million, predicts Neff of Bear Stearns.

Even with revenue shrinking, Tucci is resisting temptations to slash spending on

research and development. He’s holding it nearly flat at $800 million, or 14%

of revenue.

Advertisment

Much of it is going into software. But here, Tucci’s proposed keiretsu

threatens to punish his margins. The reason is simple: If EMC’s partners sell

its software, they hold on to a piece of the profits. Sanford C. Bernstein &

Co. analyst Toni Sacconaghi estimates that EMC’s 85% margins for direct

software sales in the midrange market will plunge to 55% in the Dell

partnership.

Tucci remains confident that he’ll be able to bolster margins in other

ways. Over the past year, he has attacked costs by trimming inventories,

reducing manufacturing and testing time, and cutting staff. For growth, he

concluded a key deal in October with Dell to sell co-branded products. This

gives EMC entrée to thousands of new customers in the midrange storage market

dominated by HP, which has a 41% share to EMC’s 6%. But competitors call it a

desperate move, one that benefits Dell more than EMC.

EMC and Dell also are crafting a plan for Dell to make a low-end storage box

designed by EMC. Royalties from the deal, Tucci says, will boost margins. He

predicts that overall gross margins will return to 45%-plus from 38.3% now–still

down from a peak of 59%.

Advertisment

Software will be the key to fatter profits, and EMC currently has the edge.

It leads its rivals with a 30.4% market share; IBM and EMC have yet to agree to

an exchange of technical specs. Tucci says he has made an offer and is still

waiting for Big Blue to respond. IBM says EMC has been resistant to open

standards.

Such difficulties are typical of an industry rife with bad blood after a

decade of EMC’s dominance. But EMC’s easy years are history. Now the onetime

storage king has to do whatever it can to keep standing on its own feet.

By Faith Keenan in Boston, with Spencer Ante in New York and

Cliff Edwards in

San Mateo, Calif in BusinessWeek. Copyright 2002 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc

Advertisment