Advertisment

DEMOCRATICALLY Speaking

author-image
DQI Bureau
New Update

Scene 1: An expert on new software that a company has developed, is

giving a presentation to a group of techies on how the product enables companies

to become more agile. He talks of the paramount need for companies to remain

competitive by spotting new opportunities and moving in for the ‘kill’

before others do. He also talks of the ability of the new software to cut costs

and remain globally competitive.

Advertisment

Scene2: A new TV commercial by a popular multinational soft drink

manufacturer shows a group of ‘heavyweights’, take on their ‘lightweight’

opponents in a football match. The heavyweights outclass and outmanoeuvre their

lightweight counterparts by their sheer agility.

“The lightning quick approval given by Premiere Zhu Rongji to Infosys is an example India should emulate”

DS Pandit

Both these scenes remind me of the debate that is raging in India on the ‘threat’

that the Chinese IT industry poses to the Indian IT industry in the globally

competitive IT market. The debate centres on the agility of the Chinese

government to make things happen at a terrific pace. There are several examples

of the quick decisions made by the Chinese.

Advertisment

Among these is the setting up of 100 hi-tech colleges all over China to churn

out highly qualified IT professionals and reducing turnaround time at ports to

help their exporters remain competitive. Another important factor that

contributes to China’s success is the size of its domestic industry due to

which it has remained insulated from the upheavals that occurred around the

world. The lightning quick approval given by the visiting Chinese Premier Zhu

Rongji to Infosys to set up an office in China is being cited as an example for

India to emulate.

It is often argued that the lead the Indian IT industry has managed to gain

over China will be nullified in a few years and unless something is done, and

done quickly. Experts on China speak of the new initiatives that the Chinese

government has taken to encourage its people to learn English. It is therefore

suggested that to maintain the lead that we enjoy over the Chinese, we must be

more agile in fashioning our responses to the challenges thrown up by the

Chinese IT industry. However, the policy initiatives to counter the Chinese

threat will come mainly from the government or will need support from the

government. And since democratic governments are not particularly known for

quick responses, this already seems like a lost cause.

On the other hand, there are others who argue that any country that does not

have a democratic polity will always have an edge over other countries that

follow the democratic system of governance. The fact that single-party

autocratic regimes are always better placed to ‘deliver the goods’ is

considered axiomatic. And therefore, unless there are radical changes in the way

we govern ourselves, our people and our businesses, there is no likelihood of

India ever managing to cope up with the rate of growth of the Chinese economy or

with China’s ability to attract foreign direct investment.

Advertisment

So, what should be done in the face of this very real and threatening

competition from China? One option is do nothing and wait for the events to

overtake us. That is the simplest thing. Not to do anything.

The second option is to be proactive. To do that, we must have a very

authentic account of what exactly is happening in China. As Nasscom chairman

Phiroz Vandrewala said at the Dataquest awards function last month, "We

would need to visit China to get a first hand account of what is happening

there. Only after that is it possible to work out a strategy to counter the

Chinese threat." Of course, a SWOT analysis is essential. And that can be

done only if conjectures and speculations are replaced with hard facts and

authentic information on what is happening in China. What is the ground level

situation there and what are the factors that are leading to this dramatic level

of growth. What are our shortcomings? Work out these isues and we will have our

action-plan.

The author is additional IT secretary, Government of Delhi. He can be

contacted at itdelhi@bol.net.in

Advertisment