|
The light at the end of the tunnel is not the headlight of an oncoming train.
While the Megaspender 2004 growth rate of 5.5% was the first sign of IT spend
recovery, there was caution in the air. However, the Megaspender 2005 analysis
of growth, of 11%, shows beyond doubt that the caution was misplaced. While the
growth is far off from the projected 26%, it would have been close to 22% but
for the huge drop in IT spending by the oil and gas major, ONGC. The traditional
IT spenders, BFS, Insurance, and telecom led the IT spend charge in 2004-05,
with each showing a robust IT spend growth in double digits.
| The
Top Spenders in Key Verticals |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
| In the BFS vertical, Punjab National Bank
(PNB) has taken the top slot. At the second spot last year, PNB continued its investments, scaling up this year as well. Recently, it announced the successful migration of its 1000th branch to core banking solution. We expect PNB to be amongst the top investors in IT in the current year as well, given its drive to bring about 2000 branches under the core banking solution. Other players in the BFS segment also saw investment scaling due to the implementation of Real Time Gross System across the banking segment. However, among the Top three IT spenders in the banking segment, the nature of investment was very different. While services accounted for about 40% for
PNB, the other two saw higher investment in hardware. Moreover, this was the case of the BFS segment in general, barring a few cases like Oriental Bank of Commerce and ING Vysya Bank, where the non-hardware investment was relatively higher. Investment in hardware continued to be a major focus area for most top players and accounted for plus 40% of total IT spend in most cases. In cases like Indian Post and Allahabad Bank, it was as high as 60%. For telecom major
BSNL, the major investment in hardware was in servers and networking, and the trend is expected to continue in the current year as well. ITC, another top investor in IT, clearly has 'services' on its mind in terms of IT spend. ITC's IT spend covers virtually everything: from supply chain management, and sales and inventory management to scientific/statistical models based procurement, and processing of tobacco leaf; from CRM for
agri-business to anywhere, anytime access to IT applications. |
|
| Growth
in Spending |
|
Verticals
|
2003-04
(Rs crore) |
2004-05
(Rs crore) |
Growth
(%) |
| Bank |
816 |
903 |
11 |
| Insurance |
53 |
84 |
58 |
| IT |
234 |
291 |
24 |
| Telecom |
352 |
574 |
63 |
| Others |
216 |
274 |
27 |
| Pharma
& Biotech |
24 |
20 |
-17 |
| Automobiles |
40 |
44 |
11 |
| Manufacturing |
931 |
770 |
-17 |
| Overall |
2,667 |
2,960 |
11 |
|
Telecom, automobiles and insurance verticals bounced back strongly to a positive growth spend, unlike last year, where the IT spend in these had dipped. Manufacturing shows a dip this year due to the oil and gas major ONGC's drop in IT by over Rs 200 crore |
|
Like mentioned later in the survey, investment in hardware was the key to
growth this year as well. Almost all the segments showed an upswing in hardware
investment. However, the structure of IT hardware spend seems to be shifting.
Till last year, the clear spend areas were PC & PC servers and non-x86
servers, however, few verticals are moving towards networking as one of the key
areas for investment. Looking at the three broad areas of IT spend-hardware,
software, and services-there seems to be some shift in the investment pattern.
Unlike the past years, where hardware accounted for over 50%, this year's
survey shows the spend on hardware falling to the 40% level. And, software moved
to the 30% level. Also, in software, the enterprises are looking at investing in
application solutions. No wonder then that ERP application is still on top of
the wish list for IT spend in the coming year. Higher software and services
investment is a sign that
the Indian enterprises are maturing and looking at IT beyond its traditional
role of automation. In one of the other parameters, it is interesting to note
that, increasingly, companies are looking at IT investments more from a business
consultancy perspective (read, business change) rather than just from the IT
consultancy preview.
| Top
IT Megaspenders 2005 |
Ranking
2003-04 |
Ranking
2004-05 |
Top
IT
Users |
Spending
2004-05 (Rs cr) |
| 1 |
1 |
BSNL |
350 |
| - |
2 |
ONGC |
200 |
| 3 |
3 |
Punjab
National Bank |
170 |
| 4 |
4 |
Bharti
Cellular |
150 |
| 10 |
4 |
Indian
Post |
150 |
| - |
6 |
ITC |
120 |
| 15 |
7 |
Allahabad
Bank |
100 |
| - |
8 |
Union Bank
of India |
80 |
| 20 |
8 |
Indian
Bank |
80 |
| 14 |
8 |
Central
Bank of India |
80 |
| 2 |
11 |
Vijaya
Bank |
70 |
| - |
11 |
Bank of
Maharashtra |
70 |
| 10 |
13 |
Hindustan
Lever |
60 |
| - |
14 |
Idea
Cellular |
50 |
| 19 |
15 |
National
Insurance Company |
49 |
| 22 |
16 |
UTI Bank |
42 |
| 13 |
17 |
BHEL |
40 |
| 16 |
17 |
BPCL |
40 |
| - |
17 |
United
Bank of India |
40 |
| - |
20 |
Oriental
Bank of Commerce |
36 |
|
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
Is it time to pop the champagne? Yes, and No. While Megaspenders 2004 had projected a growth of 26%, that did not happen. This year we saw the growth pegged at 11%. It would have been much higher but for the huge fall in IT investments by oil and gas major, ONGC, where IT spend fell by Rs 200 crore. Knock off ONGC from the list, and we have a growth of about 22%, closer to the forecasted number of 26%. And the credit for the growth goes to two verticals.
Of course, no prizes for guessing-the verticals are Banking and Telecom. Together, they account for over 60% of the Top 20 spend. Like the previous two Megaspender surveys, hardware continues to dominate the Top 20 investments, accounting for about 44% of total spend. While there has not been a change in the structure of the spend for the Top 20 companies in terms of hardware, software, and services, it is interesting to note the changes within these categories.
For instance, investment in desktop has come down from 42% to 39%, proportion of investment for servers has gone up by 3%, from the previous year's 27%. Also, there is some shift in the software side. While last year's top spenders in software, in application solutions, continues this year as well, system integration software, and application development and deployment tools have increased their share in the Top 20 spending, by a few notches. |
|
What's next
For the current year, DQ-IDC estimates a robust growth of 17% in the IT
spend of the Indian mega spenders. So, while hardware will continue to be the
driver, application deployment is expected to be on the rise. Companies will
look at ERP and other related applications like CRM, SCM to complement their
decision making process. Investments by the BFS segment will continue to be
hardware dominated, as remote location connectivity is yet to happen for a
majority of the players. However, for the hardware vendors, it is not going to
be an easy task. Given the cost pressures on hardware and the usual vendor
strategy to cut costs to ensure a win-even as the CIOs will ensure that he
gets the cheapest price- the market will get dirty on the hardware side.
Vendors will have to look at innovative bundling solutions and, maybe Linux,
especially on the desktop, which might start looking very attractive for
vendors.
| The Dominant Brands |
 |
| All companies in the sample are large enterprises |
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
|
|
This year there were some changes in the Dominant Brand category. IBM has moved up to the number one position in desktops with a 33% share, compared to 25% last year. HP's dominance in the printer and MFD segments continues unabated. Megaspender 2005 has added a few categories this year like OS, and ERP apps. No surprises there as well, with Microsoft and SAP dominating the space, respectively. Barring the printer and desktop space, it is a clear dominance of MNC brands amongst the Indian top IT users. On the desktop OS, while Microsoft need not loose sleep yet, it seems that it has lost a few points to Linux. While organizations like National Insurance have some deployment of Linux on the desktop, Linux desktops, in spite of its maturity level, and cost economics, have a long wait to find mass acceptance amongst Indian corporates. While Ramco did come out as a surprise winner in DQ Customer Satisfaction Audit 2005, as the topper, but its deployment amongst the top users in India is still very low. Given the convergence of the printing and copier media, Canon, with its array of product has moved by a notch, however, Xerox has fallen by over 10% as compared to previous year. |
|
Hardware: The Reign Continues
How did they spend their IT budgets? |
 |
| All companies in the sample are large enterprises |
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
|
|
Again, no surprises this year as well, and DQ estimates that the trend will continue for the foreseeable future. Hardware will continue to be the major component of IT spend by the corporates. As banks are moving on to the next stage of automation, the vertical will see some increase in the services spend, even as hardware dominates. As the growth in the telecom segment continues unabated, there will be a thrust on hardware spend, as seen in the graph above. However, it will not be in the conventional PC & PC servers but more on networking. Verticals like pharma and insurance saw increased software investments compared to the other verticals. |
|
| Outsourced
IT Services |
| |
Indexed
weight |
| Desktop
& Hardware Management |
59.60% |
| Network
Management (includes network consulting & integration) |
40.20% |
| Application
Management |
32.90% |
| Hosting,
Software, Maintenance |
17.80% |
| IT
Training & Education |
13.80% |
| Custom
Application Development |
11.30% |
| Business
Continuity |
10.70% |
| As expected, desktop and hardware management finds first priority for the outsourcing commitment. Facilities management and third party maintenance are now part of any IT outsourcing deal. Given the manpower concerns for all organizations, IT training and education, as an outsourced service, has moved up the rank. From last year, the number of organizations who had mentioned that they outsource training, has moved from a mere 2% up to 13% this year. However, it is surprising that a complex service like business continuity is at the bottom of the table. As per our analysis, CIOs are still not willing to take any chance of handing over the lifeline of business to outsiders. They continue to give out commoditized businesses like system management and network management, rather than business continuity. Another reason is that the number of business continuity implementations have yet to ramp up to a scale where CIOs view it seriously for outsourcing. |
|
Applications on the rise
Like the year before, where hardware gave way to applications, it is
expected to continue this year as well. Applications like ERP, CRM, and SCM will
see increased CIO interest. This will also see an increase on the services side,
and DQ estimates that business consultancy will go hand in hand with application
solutions. It is time for vendors to look at managing the business side with IT,
rather than to just sell IT solutions. Another accompanying trend is the
increasing role of the CXOs in the decision making cycle. While CXOs are getting
active, DQ expects that this year will be a year where the IT vendors will be
forced to sell solutions to CXOs, and not the CIOs. Interesting times for the
industry, the enterprise, and us.
Up Ahead
(What they'll spend on in 2005-06) |
|
Overall
|
| PCs
& PC servers |
32.4% |
| ERP
applications |
23.4% |
| Servers |
22.8% |
| Other
applications* |
9.7% |
| Networking |
9.0% |
| Datacom
& communications |
1.4% |
| Services |
1.4% |
|
|
IT
|
| PCs
& PC Servers |
66.7% |
| Servers |
16.7% |
| ERP
applications |
8.3% |
| Other
applications* |
8.3% |
|
|
Manufacturing
|
| ERP
applications |
35.3% |
| PCs
& PC servers |
29.4% |
| Servers |
17.6% |
| Other
applications* |
11.8% |
|
|
Automobiles
|
| PCs
& PC Servers |
33.3% |
| Other
applications* |
33.3% |
| Servers |
16.7% |
| ERP
applications |
16.7% |
|
|
Banking
|
| PCs
& PC servers |
33.3% |
| Servers |
33.3% |
| ERP
applications |
9.5% |
| Networking |
9.5% |
| Other
applications* |
4.8% |
| Datacom
& communications |
4.8% |
| Services |
4.8% |
|
|
Telecom
|
| Networking |
42.9% |
| ERP
applications |
28.6% |
| Servers |
14.3% |
| Services |
14.3% |
|
|
Pharma
& Biotech
|
| |
|
| Servers |
60.0% |
| PCs
& PC Servers |
40.0% |
|
|
Others
|
| PCs
& PC Servers |
31.8% |
| Servers |
31.8% |
| ERP
applications |
13.6% |
| Networking |
13.6% |
|
|
Insurance
|
| Networking |
50.0% |
| PCs
& PC servers |
25.0% |
| ERP
applications |
25.0% |
|
| *Include SCM, CRM etc |
| All companies in the sample are large enterprises |
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
| Like mentioned earlier, hardware will continue to be amongst the top IT spend for years to come. If we look at the top three investment in the current year, PC & PC servers is the top priority for most verticals, barring a few like Insurance and telecom. While the trend will continue for some more time, it is heartening to know that the percentage of PC & PC servers is expected to come down to 32% compared to last year's survey (38%). This investment is expected to move to ERP applications. For Insurance and Telecom, we expect that the top interest for CIOs lies in networking, and that's where vendors will make the money. |
|
|
| Who
spent the most on IT? |
| |
Overall |
Banking |
Insurance |
IT |
Telecom |
Pharma |
Automobiles |
Manufacturing |
Others |
| Average
PCs |
2,771 |
6,270 |
4,175 |
5,521 |
6,010 |
2,317 |
1,075 |
1,434 |
1,388 |
| Employees
per PC |
5.4 |
2.3 |
1.5 |
1.2 |
11.4 |
2 |
4.7 |
5.7 |
21.7 |
| IT
spend per employee (Rs Lakh) |
0.1 |
0.3 |
0.3 |
0.4 |
0.1 |
0.1 |
0.2 |
0.1 |
0.1 |
| IT
spend as % of Revenues |
0.2 |
0.1 |
1.5 |
1.9 |
0.9 |
0.3 |
0.3 |
0.2 |
0.6 |
| The IT industry has regained its top place in terms of IT spend per employee. However, IT spend per employee has come down from the earlier 0.5 lakh to 0.4 lakh. Also, interestingly, the number of employee per PC has gone down. While last year we estimated seven employees for a PC, this year's data shows that that has come down to five employees per PC. Given the huge investment made by the IT and Insurance players, we are getting to a situation where the sample companies in these verticals have a one employee per PC ratio |
|
Up Ahead
(What they'll spend on in 2005-06) |
 |
|
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
|
|
Like mentioned earlier, hardware would continue to drive the growth in the Indian IT industry. Hardware, like in the past, will account for about 40% of the IT spend by enterprises. However, the spend structure in hardware will change from vertical to vertical. For example, in telecom and insurance, the spend will be skewed towards networking and not PC & PC servers. However, in comparison with the previous year, it is clear that the hardware will fall as a percentage of total spend (49% last year), as investment will move towards software and services |
|
 |
| All companies in the sample are large enterprises |
Source: DQ-IDC India Survey: Megaspenders 2005 |
|
|
RFID is still being talked about, but it is interesting to know that about 12% of the sampled enterprises are already using some form of it. As one would have expected, manufacturing has taken the lead in RFID implementation, with about seven companies deploying RFID within their organization. Wi-Fi/WLAN has also moved out of the shadows and is going mainstream. The last survey indicated that about 26% of the sample organizations have deployed some form of it. This figure has now shot up to 46%. Again, one of the key verticals, which has taken this technology, is manufacturing. |
|
Yograj Varma in New
Delhi With inputs from Nikhil Pant (Analyst end-user research, IDC India)
Next Page : METHODOLOGY Page(s) 1 2
|