Today's call centers are manned by 22-year-olds, transient and waiting for a bigger break. Of tomorrow, no one knows. And that's giving recruiters, already fighting attrition of over 60%, sleepless night
WANTED... Any and every 22-something, graduate with excellent command over the English
language and communication skills. Previous experience in dealing with clients
will be preferred and an added advantage, but is not an imperative. For
interviews, please contact the undersigned...
CANDIDATE profile... Preferably holding a bachelor’s degree (in any stream) with 0-3 years of
experience, preferably in the service industry; willing to work in shifts.
The REWARDS... Earn while you learn, and grow. Work with a company that applies Six Sigma
quality procedures and services clients from across the globe. Transportation
and all meals will be provided. Boarding facilities are also available during
night shifts.
Sounds familar? It’s all over the place, in the career section of every
newspaper and IT trade publication—ad upon ad upon ad from companies of the
like and genre of General Electric, Daksh eServices, Convergys and Infowavz...
And there’s a common theme running through these ads—"Catch the 22
Tribe", the MTV generation that is ready and all-equipped to do what is
asked of them this side of the headset.
Skip
to the other side of the globe—the enthusiasm and excitement has long tapered
off and is missing from the ads. For the business has matured and settled down—there’s
no learning and growing here, no excitement, just another job. Check out this
typical candidate profile—knowledge of basic computer operations; willingness
to rotate shifts, as needed; ability to learn; courteous with strong customer
service orientation; dependable with proficient attention to detail; good
listening and responding skills; 8-hour shifts; start time of 10 am. Period. And
the kind of people holding these jobs—usually housewives, well past their best
years.
Compare the ambience of the workplaces there and here, and the difference is
striking. At one end of the spectrum (overseas), it’s ‘dreary’ brown and
depressing, while offices on the other side of the hemisphere (here) are hip,
hot and happening—bright and college-like, with cafeterias and gymnasiums more
the norm than the exception.
Other
Services (includes remote education, data search market research,
networks, consultancy & management)
1,400
2,000
20,000
Total
45,000
70,000
11,00,000
Source: Nasscom
*Dataquest estimates
Says Krishnan Dhawan, chief marketing officer of exl Service.com, "The
quality of our facility is far superior to what is usually available in the US.
I guess this has more to do with the demographics of the two locations."
But young, trendy and happening describes this new breed of 22-year-olds. But
hold on...before venturing further into the ‘Catch 22’—the average age of
the ITeS employee in India is 22 years— situation, let’s go back two years
and take a look at the genesis of the ITeS brigade.
The roots Globally, companies have always sought new ways to increase profitability,
either by increased revenues or cutting costs. Outsour-cing work to countries
like India—where per-employee costs are about one-tenth or one-eighth that of
similarly skilled people in the US and the UK—reaps huge benefits. Also, given
the low-paying and unexciting nature of the ITeS job, call centers in the US and
UK find it difficult to get enough suitably-literate employees willing to work
at the wages offered. Even in the post-slowdown scenario, ITeS jobs are not hot
and aspired for in developed countries. However, as the US economy falters, and
more companies scramble to cut costs and maintain profit margins, outsourcing
remains a high priority for them.
“We have been going to smaller cities and hiring people. And our experience has shown us that they stick to their jobs much longer”
So while companies have been looking to outsource for some time, an analysis
in 1999 didn’t brand India as an "ideal destination for IT-enabled
services". The country was lagging far behind others like Ireland,
Australia, the UK and the Netherlands. While India had a large and low-cost pool
of English-speaking prospective employees, infrastructure was the key weakness
and concern. However, that’s all history today—India’s ITeS revenues are
nearly five times that of the nearest competitor. What was it that—in a short
span of two-three years—created a new ITeS industry, showing growth rates of
50%-plus, even in times of the slowdown?
First, infrastructural bottlenecks like telecom and power have been cleared,
especially in the metros. Second, and more important, companies are realizing
that India’s large, low-cost English speaking talent pool will remain the most
important advantage in the long run. Even in extreme scenarios of wages growing
at 9-10% per annum, India will continue to enjoy the cost advantage for the next
decade. Says Planetworkz Senior vice-president Suren Singh Rasaily, "It
took the IT industry 25 years to create 500,000 jobs, all put together. It has
taken the ITeS space three years to create 100,000 jobs, and this is set to rise
to 1.1 million in another six years."
However, growth has been restricted to a few pockets of India—it began in
Mumbai and the NCR region (Delhi, Gurgaon, and Noida) and moved on to Bangalore.
So what’s next?
Will the dream run continue? Let’s look at the big issue that ITeS companies are grappling with. To
begin with—attrition. The industry is growing rapidly, thanks to the high
availability of English speaking 22-somethings in the metro areas. Given the
Indian population and heavy competition in practically every other job segment,
here’s a new area offering a decent Rs 8,000-12,000 to a graduate, a fresher
holding his first job. This is a dream come true, and that’s how so many
22-somethings have been roped in. The thing to remember here—the numbers
joining are huge, but so is the numbers leaving. Plain and simple, the
IT-enabled services segment is being manned by youngsters, transient and waiting
for a bigger break—exams for competitive fields, admission into a foreign
university, or clear time-pass while waiting to join in in the family business.
Industry estimates show that 15-18% of the employees move on to higher
studies. Another 28-33% quit the industry altogether because of job pressure and
tough timings. The balance continues with the job, as alternative and lucrative
job options are not easily available in the country. Of those that leave, 10-15%
quit in the first two months itself—and that’s the most disturbing trend
being dreaded but suffered by all ITeS companies.
According to a Nasscom-McKinsey report, the cost of replacing a knowledge
worker is about 1.5-2 times his salary. Also, additional costs of turnover—intellectual
capital, especially when transferred to competitors, and decrease in ‘bench
strength’ needed for effective succession planning—are not easy to measure.
The Changing Face
What the IT services and IT-enabled services industries will do:
n The industry’s share of GDP will increase from the 1.4% it as in 2001 to 7% by 2008 and the industry will account for 19% of incremental GDP growth from now to 2008.
n More than 30% of all foreign exchange earned will be from IT and ITeS exports
n As many as 4 million jobs will be created—2 million directly and 2 million indirectly by way of support services
n India will be firmly placed on the global technology map as a major technology hub
TransWorks CEO Prakash Gurbaxani agrees: "Lower attrition rates will
have both a financial and non-financial impact." Apart from attrition,
another issue waiting in the wings is cost-pressures. Given the mushrooming of
ITeS players in the metros, the average cost of employees is on the increase.
While the starting salary a year ago was about Rs 6,000-8,000, it’s between Rs
8,000 and Rs 12,000 now. Apart from direct employee costs, indirect employee
cost is also eating into ITeS companies’ cash reserves. Of the total recurring
costs, close to 40-45% goes toward employees and employee-related activities,
according to a study conducted by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and
KPMG. It becomes imperative, therefore, for ITeS players to start looking at
other low-cost alternatives.
Look at ITeS as a career prospect from the perspective of those who live in
these smaller cities. They offer a good salary, which is a scarce commodity
there. People find it imperative to migrate to metros in search of a decent
livelihood and lifestyle.
Consider alternative careers—a recent ad seeking a research associate or
assistant. The candidate had to have a minimum qualification of a post-graduate
degree in management or the social sciences, with two years’ experience. A
further MPhil or PhD was preferred. The pay packet—Rs 6,000-10,000, depending
on suitability. So the candidate, who would have spent four more years than a
graduate on higher studies, ends up earning less than the latter in an ITeS job.
Given such daunting job prospects, setting up ITeS centers in such locations
could ensure that people flock in to sign up with ITeS firms. The ITeS boom has
got people migrating from ‘B’ & ‘C’ class cities in search of good
career opportunities. On the other hand, few companies are moving upcountry to
bag more employees.
Companies like GE have moved a step further and set up centers in ‘B’
& ‘C’ class cities like Jaipur. MsourcE CEO Milind Chalisgaon-kar
agrees, "People from smaller cities in the same state, as well as from
neighboring states, apply to our centers in Bangalore and Pune. For instance, a
number of people from Goa, Coimbatore, Hubli, Dharwad, Nasik and Nagpur are
working in our centers."
Also, it helps companies save on costs. Says LS Ram, executive director of
Cross Domain, "Companies will venture into ‘B’ & ‘C’ class
cities to save on costs, only if operational risks are manageable—and once
they go there, they will not pay metro-level salaries."
Zia Sheikh
CEO and co-founder, Infowavz
“The moot question is–How many small-city graduates have the language and cultural skills to successfully support all the global customers that contact centers cater to?”
While the movement has started in a small way, it will take time to percolate
to non-metro cities. It has taken some time even for metros to build the support
infrastructure—like transport and catering, apart from telecom and power.
Largescale movements to smaller cities, therefore, will take a while. Another
big problem with smaller cities is that English is not a very common language
there. For companies that take on these people, therefore, this implies
additional training, and therefore greater costs. Then there’s the issue with
accents, as is the case in many southern states. Comments Zia Sheikh, CEO and
co-founder of Infowavz, "While everyone talks about more than a million
English-speaking people graduating from Indian universities every year, the moot
question is—‘How many of these graduates actually have the language skills
and cultural knowledge to successfully support global customers?’ The answer
is a very small proportion, perhaps not more than 5%." It is simply not a
case of one size fits all.
Also given the enthusiasm and drive of the younger brigade, is there room for
the middle-aged in the ITeS industry? In the US, it’s middle-aged housewives
who (wo)man the call centers in a major way. Globally, the BPO and call center
space tends to attract a lot of women, as it is a stable job, with fixed hours.
Agrees Ram, "Women are more conscientious and tend to be comfortable
handling a repetitive job with equal ease." But the chances for Indian
women are not big as yet. While in the US, women work normal work hours, Indian
women have problems working with erratic hours, due to the time difference (most
of the clients being serviced are based out of countries in vastly different
time zones).
Catch All Given the rapid strides made by ITeS players, it is unlikely that the
current metro turnouts will suffice the HR requirement of all the players.
Explains Rasaily: "We have to reach out to the smaller cities for this, for
it will be these people who will make up the basic workforce in contact centers
in the longer run."
ITeS is hot and everyone is latching onto this bandwagon—from individuals
to companies to state governments. Given the fact that it has a potential to
employ over a million people by 2008, state governments—Andhra Pradesh, Kerala,
Gujarat and Maharashtra—are giving emphasis to and producing English-speaking
graduates with the right domain and functional expertise. The Kerala government
is investing Rs 2 crore in ITeS human resource training initiatives.
The lack of telecom and technology infrastructure has inhibited growth in
these states so far, but with state governments competing aggressively to
attract call center players, infrastructure is bound to improve.
And while it is too soon is to see city-dwellers saying no to ITeS jobs, the
composition of the workforce is bound to undergo a sea change—so here’s to
the changing face of the Indian ITeS worker. May it be a happy one.